Comparison of Foot and Mouth Disease (FMD) and Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy (BSE)
**Both
diseases are foreign animal diseases – neither occurs in the United States
|
|
Foot
and mouth disease (FMD) |
Bovine
spongiform encephalopathy (BSE) |
|
Infectious
Agent |
Virus |
Prion (altered normal protein)-? |
|
Animals
affected |
Cloven-hoofed
animals including cattle, swine, sheep, goats, deer, elk, wildebeest |
Cattle;
there are other Transmissible Spongiform Encephalopathies such as scrapie
in sheep, Chronic Wasting Disease (CWD) in deer and elk, Cruetzfeldt Jacob
Disease (CJD) of people |
|
Distribution |
All
continents except North America, Australia, Antarctica |
31
countries including the U.K. and a number of E.U. countries |
|
Characteristics
of Disease |
Acute,
systemic infection causing fever and blisters on lips, tongue, gums,
teats, and hooves; symptoms are lameness, salivation, reduced appetite,
decreased milk production. |
Chronic,
progressive degenerative disease of the central nervous system; symptoms
include changes in behavior, incoordination, abnormal posture, falling
down, difficulty rising |
|
Incubation
period |
From
2 – 14 days |
From
2 – 8 years |
|
Age
at onset |
Any
age |
Generally
older than 3 years of age; most cases are in dairy cows between 3 and 6
years of age |
|
How
transmitted |
Direct
(animal to animal) and indirect contact with contaminated feed, water,
insects, clothing, vehicles; people and vehicles can carry the virus from
animal to animal or farm to farm; semen and embryos can be infective |
Consumption
of feed contaminated with the prion (bone meal); there is no evidence BSE
is transmitted horizontally (animal to animal); vertical transmission
(mother to offspring) may occur at a low level |
|
Treatment |
Symptomatic |
None |
|
Recovery |
Usually |
No |
|
Mortality
Rate (Death Rate) |
Low;
high in very young animals |
High;
virtually 100% |
|
Morbidity
Rate (Infection Rate) |
High;
virtually 100% of exposed |
Unknown |
|
|
Foot
and mouth disease (FMD) |
Bovine
spongiform encephalopathy (BSE) |
|
How
Diagnosed |
Clinical
signs; confirmed by laboratory tests (virus detection or isolation,
positive serology) |
Clinical
signs; testing of brain after slaughter; live animal tests are being
developed |
|
Zoonotic
Concern (does it affect people) |
No;
(only a few cases ever reported; mild symptoms) |
Yes;
people that have consumed meat products derived from cattle; disease in
people is called vCJD |
|
Food
Safety Issue in Affected Countries |
No |
Yes;
high risk materials include brain, spinal cord, nerves, intestines, lymph
nodes, spleen |
|
Pathways
of Entry into the U.S. |
Infected
ruminants and swine; contaminated ruminant and swine products; civilian
and military passengers with contaminated clothing or foot gear or
carrying prohibited products; airborne (>10 km-land; 100 km-over
water); contaminated farm equipment and cargo containers; pets with
contaminated hair coats |
Importation
of cattle incubating the disease and/or contaminated rendered material |
|
Primary
risk reduction strategy in the U.S. |
Prohibition
of imports of live ruminants and swine, and products of ruminants and
swine from countries with FMD |
Prohibition
of live cattle, cattle products, and rendered materials from countries
with BSE (1989 for U.K.; extended to E.U. in 1997) |
|
Other
U.S. Safeguards |
Inspection
of passengers and baggage for prohibited products (x-ray of baggage,
interviewing passengers, dog teams that can detect prohibited products);
prohibition of dirty farm equipment; disinfection of dirty foot gear |
Voluntary
cessation of use of adult sheep in cattle feed (1989); mammalian to
ruminant feed ban (1997); targeted surveillance activities; tracing,
quarantine of cattle imported before importation ban, and testing of them
after euthanasia |
|
Vaccine |
Yes
but must be specific to the virus type; use of vaccination tightly
controlled |
No
vaccine |
|
Eradication
Strategy Used by Affected Countries |
Euthanasia
and disposal of infected and exposed animals; milk also must be treated
and disposed of; strict movement controls |
Slaughter
of clinical cases and herd of origin; infected herds are rendered;
rendered product incinerated; incinerated product buried; age limitation
for (normal) slaughtered animals |
|
Resistance
to inactivation |
Susceptible
to heat, low or high pH, specific disinfectants (e.g. lye, strong chlorine
solutions) |
Resistant
to heat, UV light, ionizing radiation and common disinfectants; rendering
does not inactivate the agent |
Prepared by: Dr. R. D. Willer
Return to VMAT or AAVDM Homepage
State Veterinarian
State of Arizona
602-542-4293
602-542-4290 fax